Editor's Profile
Michael Field

 

Read the others

 

 

 

EXCLUSIVE: THE INDIAN VOYAGE OF MICHAEL FIELD
Temple tourists
by Michael Field
Occasionally one goes through an experience which, in its sum total offers a useful lesson on life, one worth sharing. Two came up today; about 60 kilometres is the limit to which the average Western body can endure riding in an auto rickshaw. Lesson two; do not buy your auto rickshaw driver a beer. In lesson two rickshaw driver can also be substituted with Thai boatman. Explanations later.
Mahabalipuram is a World Heritage Site; a collection of stone carvings and temples dating from the 3rd to 8th Centuries. A number of kings who ruled the region had artistic bents and exercised them in a series of striking buildings and ornate carvings. In this part of the world they are a prime tourist attraction, not just for foreigners but also for the tens of thousands of domestic tourists who, in an era of discount airlines and widely available cars, not explore the homeland with a strange fierceness. It may well spell doom for Mahabalipuram if this all keeps up.
I found my driver and negotiated a price for the trip; 1200 rupees. As we went on this was, it seems, exclusive of various charges including tolls, drinks and meals. No matter. Heading south he was a good driver in the lose sense that the roads are a challenge to the manhood of every idiot in India who wants to drive. I used to find the apparent anarchy of places like Mumbai and Kolkata bad enough, but in Chennai there are fewer cars. This just not mean more control and reason; it simply means high speed anarchy.
Clear of Chennai we moved down the blistering coast, pounded by unyielding heat without a breath of wind. Little wonder people in these parts hanker for the monsoon. What they got several years ago was the 2002 Boxing Day Asian Tsunami. Its impact can be seen easily with long tracts of coastline stripped of vegetation which only now is beginning to recover. Refugee camps remain, although they are far from full as villages have been rebuilt. Boats sit on the beach, many with the propaganda of an alphabet soup of global NGOs who could not bring themselves to give aid without singing about their charity loudly. Long live the NGO which gives something without putting up its name and a press statement.
The town of Mahabalipuram is a much more recent addition to the landscape. Lord, the tackiness of tourism - and this is far from an Indian speciality - seems to know no bounds. The sheer volume of rubbish being sold in the name of art is quite extraordinary. I was almost inclined to buy the stone “Karma Sutra” thing for the amusement of others. But being made out of granite it could have easily blown my luggage allowance. At one monument I was set upon by an “engineer student” (once assumes that in tourist knickknack school they tell you to come up with a line to appeal) who wanted to sell me a marble elephant. On the way in he failed, but was waiting as I came out. He had a price: 1200 rupees. We walked on and he came up with a good line: “As you are not American, I will give you this for just 800 rupees.” Surely he has a variation on that: “as you are American … etc etc”. As I neared the rickshaw the price was down to 400 rupees. Moments as we were to drive away the price was 200 rupees. What margins they work on!
The statues and temples are worth seeing, absolutely no question, but tourists are crushing them. The Shore Temple - the icon piece of the whole place - is being crawled over, literally, but hundreds of tourists. I am not at all sure many of them seriously care about it all; its just another trophy to visit and chalk up. Rocks are falling apart and being worn out by the ceaseless flow of people each day. At the Five Rathas beautiful stone elephants and lions - nearly 2000 years old - were being used as props for family photos. Children were throwing ice cream containers on the ground and many were simply bored, working their mobile phones instead.
India, by seeking World Heritage listing for Mahabalipuram, owes the world better than this. The places can be seen, but with delicacy; it is unnecessary to have everybody clambering over the buildings.
There is a serious disconnect between the beauty of it all and the management of the sites. Its shown up in the bizarre plaques set up to inform visitors. They are, for the most part, incomprehensible in English. They may well make a useful introduction to a PhD dissertation, but they have no passion, romance or store telling for modern visitors.
Mahabalipuram needs urgent, desperate help. India is a land of exquisite beauties; they could simply all die the death of 10,000 tourist cuts.
In the way of the world, we left and headed north with the rickshaw driver going to his preferred resort for lunch. I felt strange; I was surrounded by all these pasty white people. Italians, Germans. I am not at all sure of the attraction of South Indian beaches; they are unrelentingly hot and featureless. Lunch was on me, it seems. My driver ordered himself a big dish and a Kingfisher. I settled for just the beer and some fruit. All seemed well and we set out for Chennai.
My driver had completely changed from the trip down. The mellow, philosophical man had become all aggressive, loud and distinctly risky to be with. He would yell out at people and act erratically. When he proposed - as all rickshaw drivers do - to take me to a handicraft shop (“just for looking, just for 10 minutes“) I made it clear he would lose his ride at that point if he persisted. He sulked and got even more erratic. And it was only one beer!

-- published on January 14, 2007 --
To coment this article to the blog click here
 

Asia News - LaSpecula.com International News Weekly

Are you Asia? Do you want write with us? Just contact our redaction!